Thursday, January 4, 2018

A Sydney conservationist's perspective on the 1982 NSW rainforest decison

A Sydney conservationist's perspective on the 1982 NSW rainforest decison

by Peter Prineas.


A photograph appeared in the Sydney Morning Herald late in 2017 of north coast artist and conservationist Dailan Pugh. Bearded and bare-footed, he is shown perched on the stump of a gum tree. In an article by the Herald’s environment reporter, Peter Hannam, Pugh decries the Environment Protection Authority’s inadequate response to complaints of destruction in Cherry Tree State Forest near Grafton. [1]

Pugh's anger at being told of the EPA’s decision not to prosecute, just a week before the time limit expired, was understandable. The EPA’s reasons for not taking action were weak:

“The EPA's claim that someone else could have come in while logging was underway without anyone noticing and caused the damage on numerous occasions is totally preposterous,” Pugh said.

The EPA was also unable, or unwilling, to counter the Forestry Corporation's defence that only regrowth forest was damaged.

It was left to Elaine Johnson of the Environmental Defender’s Office to make the point that if the public had not been stripped of their right to enforce environmental laws in the forests, things might have been different:

“The absence of third-party appeal rights deprives the public of the opportunity to bring matters to the courts in circumstances where the EPA decides not to prosecute," she said.

There have been other failures by the EPA to bring the Forestry Corporation to book. In 2013 a logging road was pushed through a protected koala habitat in Whian Whian Forest near Lismore but the EPA took so long to act that the time to prosecute ran out. [2]

According to another news report, the Forestry Corporation was fined 46 times in the five years up to 2015 for breaches of threatened species regulations, polluting waters, failing to mark trees or exclusion zones and not searching effectively for koala habitats. [3] The fines were obviously too small to act as a deterrent.

However, some reported comments by the EPA on a proposed new regulatory framework for native forests suggest that it has not completely lost its edge. According to the Herald’s Peter Hannam, the EPA criticised conflicts of interest in licence arrangements, the Forestry Corporation’s immunity from legal challenges by community groups, and the small financial penalties that can be imposed. [4]

My interest in this subject arises partly from my past association with the EPA Board. I was one of two members in the 2000s nominated by the Nature Conservation Council of NSW, and appointed by the Minister, Bob Debus; the other was Dr Judy Henderson who joined the Board some years earlier. My involvement with the EPA Board was part-time and hardly central to the Authority’s role, yet it did have some influence. The Board determined when the EPA should prosecute for serious environmental offences and it was, I think, sufficiently independent of the EPA to undertake this role.

Some years after I left the EPA Board it was abolished by the O’Farrell government. Later it was reconstituted in a different form. It had lost its independent chair, with the EPA’s Chief Executive Officer chairing the meetings. The Nature Conservation Council and other community bodies had lost their right to nominate people for appointment by the Minister. It looked more like a board from the ‘big end of town’.

My earlier involvement in forestry issues also leads me to take an interest in the recent disputes, and although I applaud Dailan Pugh's achievements in helping to conserve biodiversity in our native forests, I do not always agree with his account of what happened in the past. 

I participated in the rainforest campaign of the 1970s and early 80s as the Executive Officer of the National Parks Association of NSW. This brands me as one those ‘Sydney conservationists,’ Dailan seems to dislike, but I will nevertheless continue.

In his monograph ‘A Conservationist’s Perspective on Conservation in North East NSW,’ published on the web in 2016 [5]  Dailan states that the “Sydney groups thought that Terania Creek was an insignificant area, a ‘Not In My Backyard’ issue.” [6]  As a general statement this is not true.

The campaign by Sydney conservation groups for a national park in the Border Ranges – earlier proposed by local people in the Border Ranges Preservation Society – began in 1975 with the slogan 'The last Rainforest'. We soon realised it was not the last rainforest, and within a few years the campaign broadened to encompass all the major rainforest areas, including the Nightcap Range.



I was contacted by Nan Nicholson of the Terania Native Forest Action Group early in 1976 and accepted an article from her for publication in the ‘National Parks Journal’. The article presented a case for the reservation of Terania Basin as a Nature Reserve. It was published in the March/April 1976 issue under the title ‘Terania Creek Basin’ and covered several pages including an aerial photograph and a map. The map was specially drawn by Kaj Elenius, the husband of the then Hon. Editor of the 'Journal,' Elizabeth Elenius. Furthermore, we published a critique of the Forestry Commission’s misuse of data to justify the proposed logging. This was authored by an anonymous Sydney ornithologist (I think it was David Milledge) and ran to a couple of pages under the title, ‘Terania Creek – Forestry Argument Unsound’.

The Sydney environment groups invested much time and effort – too much in fact – in the Terania Creek Commission of Inquiry – the Isaacs Inquiry – which ran for over a year. Many groups including the Nature Conservation Council, the Colong Committee and the Total Environment Centre made submissions. I spent many days at the Inquiry representing the NPA and assisting Nan Nicholson of TNFAG. With Elizabeth Elenius I produced a comprehensive analysis of the arguments put to the Inquiry and published it in 1981 as a supplement to the 'National Parks Journal' entitled ‘Why Log Terania Creek’. [7] I also produced for NPA a national park proposal for the Nightcap Range including Terania Creek, to be placed before the Inquiry. When Commissioner Isaacs rejected this document as ‘irrelevant,’ NPA withdrew as a party.

Dailan mentions that logging on the Nightcap Range, “was stopped by a legal case in 1982, under the newly introduced Environmental Planning and Assessment Act. The judge determined that an Environmental Impact Statement, an EIS, was required before logging continued.” [8]  Dailan does not mention the name of this case, which was Kivi v Forestry Commission. He could be excused for not knowing that the letter to the Forestry Commission demanding an EIS, on which the applicant Dianne Kivi relied, had been sent months before by NPA in Sydney. Barrister Murray Wilcox put NPA’s Nightcap National Park proposal into evidence and I was called as a witness to speak to it. NPA’s proposal for a national park helped in obtaining a favourable judgement from the Court.

Kivi’s case was one of the first actions taken under Part 5 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act. This provision enabled citizens to restrain forestry operations where the Forestry Commission had failed to take significant impacts on the environment into account. But even before Kivi, NPA had a commenced a Part 5 action – Prineas v Forestry Commission – to stop rainforest logging in the Hastings Valley forests. There it was argued by our counsel, Murray Wilcox, that although an Environment Impact Statement had been produced by the Forestry Commission, it was inadequate. This was a tougher case to argue than Kivi and we failed to get the injunction sought from the Court. However it was still a win as the logging in the Hastings Valley rainforests was stopped long enough for the area to be added to the conservation groups’ claim and ultimately included in the Wran government’s rainforest decision.

Dailan further states: “In June 1982, with the NPA, I proposed the creation of 7 flora reserves in the Urbenville Area to protect the best bits of rainforest remaining. Other conservation groups wouldn’t support us, they said it was because we were only proposing flora reserves and not national parks, though it probably had more to [do with] their advocating these rainforests as a trade-off.” [9]

In referring to the NPA, Dailan must mean its Far North Coast branch. NPA also had branches at Port Macquarie and Grafton which made strong contributions to protecting the rainforests in their areas. Dailan's proposal for flora reserves at Urbenville appeared after the rainforest campaign had been running for seven years and just a few months before the Wran government announced its decision. Even if these proposals had been supported, it was too late to bring them into the settlement about to be made.

It was clear that withdrawing the major rainforest areas from logging would force the closure of the veneer mills unless they could convert their operations to processing eucalypt hardwoods. The government was concerned to leave some rainforest resources for a phase-out period. The areas Dailan identified in the Urbenville forests were part of the alternative resources identified by the government to sustain Munro and Lever’s mill at Grevillea which was about to lose the bulk of its resource in the Border Ranges. The government also spent a lot of money establishing a new pine plantation for the benefit of this mill. The rainforest resource at Urbenville was not great and could not amount to a ‘trade-off’ for the extensive areas the conservation groups claimed – the state forests of the Border Ranges, the Nightcap Range, Washpool, the Black Scrub, the Forbes River Valley and Barrington Tops, among others. These areas would soon be transferred to the National Parks and Wildlife Service and later form part of the World Heritage listed Central Eastern Rainforest Reserves of Australia (CERRA).

As it happened, after the rainforest decision was made the Grevillea mill closed and in 1986 Dailan's proposals were mostly realised when the Forestry Commission placed 2273 hectares of rainforest in flora reserves; these were later incorporated into the CERRA World Heritage Area.

He goes on to say that after the Wran government’s rainforest decision was made, “Half the rainforests were left under State Forests control and logging continued.” [10]  Not only that, those pernicious Sydney conservation groups, “had done a deal with the government and so proclaimed that the rainforests had been saved, even though rainforest logging continued and significant areas of wilderness remained unprotected.” [11]

There was no 'deal'. The conservation groups publicly welcomed the government’s decision because it was a good one. It would have been foolish to reject it and immediately demand more. The large areas of rainforest the veneer mills needed to sustain their operations had been withdrawn. Funds were provided to assist them to transition to non-rainforest resources. There was to be an early phase-out of general purpose rainforest logging.


It is misleading to suggest that after the Wran government's decision, half of the rainforests were still available for logging. The areas that remained were, with a few exceptions, in scattered patches too small to keep the veneer mills going for long, and the rest was inaccessible, fringing watercourses or mixed with sclerophyll forest.

The days of rainforest trees being made into concrete formwork were over and Keith Jordan, the Director of the Forests Products Association, correctly described the 1982 rainforest decision as “a staggering blow to the industry”. Within months, the veneer mills at Kyogle, Coffs Harbour, Kempsey, Armidale, Yarras and Wauchope closed. The mill at Grevillea followed them not long after, and the Big River Timbers mill at Grafton moved out of rainforest logging and began making veneer from eucalypt hardwoods. In the history of NSW state forests there has been no event – before or since – that compares with the Wran government’s 1982 rainforest decision.

If Dailan did not like the rainforest decision, neither did the forestry establishment. Something I wrote in the 'National Parks Journal' at the time was deemed offensive by one of the unions and used as an excuse to ban my correspondence with the Forestry Commission (similarly the NPA’s). The ban continued for a long time with the tacit approval of the Forests Commissioner, Dr. Wal Gentle, and the endorsement of the Minister, Jack Hallam.

It is true that old growth forests like North Washpool and Chaelundi had to wait for their salvation until after 1989, when the North East Forest Alliance (NEFA) came onto the scene. NEFA and its members, especially Dailan Pugh and John Corkill, deserve much credit for the actions they took to protect these and other forest areas. They earned the 'gongs' they were awarded in 2003 and the recognition they received, although an article in the ‘Good Weekend’ magazine would have been better without its remarks about “mainstream conservationists” who “clung to their chandeliers”. This was not a fair characterisation of the Sydney NGOs. It also failed to acknowledge the support given to John Corkill who spent a lot of time in Sydney and used the facilities of the NCC office.

Dailan says that “over the 15 years from 1989 to 2004 NEFA was primarily responsible for 881,849 hectares being added to the reserve system in north east NSW as well as 310,000 hectares of State Forests being included in Special Management Zones which are protected from logging under the Forestry Act 1916. That is 218 hectares a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year.” [12]

Did the Wilderness Act 1987 contribute nothing to these additions? That Act of course was an initiative of the Sydney conservation groups. I will leave it to others to scrutinise the figures, noting that the primary responsibility for decisions affecting state forests belongs to the NSW government, and that contributions made by other organisations might be worth a mention, "secondary" though they may be.

It has been mentioned that NEFA and other NSW environment groups – and even the EPA – are concerned at the inadequate regulation of the Forestry Corporation’s operations in state forests. This situation did not come about by accident. It was an outcome of the Regional Forests Agreements.

Dailan recounts how he was appointed in 1995 as a member of the NSW Resource and Conservation Assessment Council, a high level state government body which he describes as “tasked with overseeing the forest assessment process in NSW”. He says RACAC was “based on a process involving balanced representation of stakeholders initially put forward by NEFA and championed by The Greens in their pre-election negotiations with the ALP” and that its goals were “to implement the requirements of the National Forest Policy to identify a comprehensive, adequate and representative reserve system and ecologically sustainable forest management.” [13] 



‘Balanced representation’ is not a phrase that comes to mind when considering RACAC’s line-up of top public servants.  [14]  

Dailan writes: “between 1995 and 1998 most of NEFA’s attention and effort was focussed on the forest assessment process being overseen by RACAC.” He “represented NEFA on RACAC, the Steering Committee and the Environment and Heritage Technical Working group” and NEFA and the South East Forests Alliance (SEFA) were also “represented on working groups for Socio-economics, Ecologically Sustainable Forest Management and resource assessments”.



Sydney conservation groups did not get a place at the RACAC table but I recall that some people seemed to be 'in the loop'.

The Regional Forestry Agreements process was a grand exercise in deal-making. It offered the promise of a ‘Comprehensive, Adequate and Representative reserve’ system for Australian forests in return for peace in the forests and certainty for the industry. 

A down-payment on the expanded forests reserve system in NSW was made in 1996 by the Carr government, however it fell a long way short of the area needed to meet National Reserve Criteria, which by 1998 had been applied and estimated at over a million hectares of additional reserves – just for north east NSW! Not surprisingly, this figure was negotiated downwards around the RACAC table – and no doubt in the corridors – first to 554,000 hectares and then to 411,000 hectares at which point Dailan says, “We did not agree with this outcome, and immediately instigated a token blockade at Bald Knob.” But the RFA process was not susceptible to blockades and three Regional Forest Agreements were made, Premier Bob Carr signing for NSW, and Prime Minister John Howard for the Commonwealth.

The other side of the deal – major changes to the regulatory regime in the forests – is not mentioned in Dailan’s ‘Perspective’, but their progress through the RFA negotiations was never in doubt. At the state level they were enacted by the Forestry and National Park Estate Act 1998. In summary, this Act provides [15] that where forestry operations are subject to an Integrated Forestry Operations Approval (IFOA):

• Part 5 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 does not apply.

• An environmental planning instrument under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 cannot prohibit, require development consent for, or otherwise restrict, forestry operations.

• Part 4 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 has no effect.

• Certain orders made under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 do not have effect.

• Stop work orders and interim protection orders) of the National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974 do not apply.

• Stop work orders of the Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995 do not apply.

• An order under section 124 of the Local Government Act 1993 does not have effect.

• The Wilderness Act 1987 and the wilderness provisions of the National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974 do not apply.

• Provisions of Acts or instruments made under them that give any person a right to institute proceedings in a court to remedy or restrain a breach (or a threatened or apprehended breach) of the Act – the so-called ‘third party appeal rights’ – do not apply.

These restrictions do not affect proceedings brought by a Minister, or by the Environment Protection Authority, or in limited circumstances by other government agencies and officials. However when governments fail to act as they should, the lack of public access to proceedings under Part 5 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act and to third party enforcement proceedings in various Acts, not to mention the processes of the Wilderness Act, becomes obvious.

At the Commonwealth level, the Regional Forest Agreements and their IFOAs gave wood products a free pass under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999, the Export Control Act 1982 and the Australian Heritage Commission Act 1975. [16]

We are yet to see the results of an official review of the Regional Forest Agreements but there have been some unofficial ones. In May 2016 Dr Oisin Sweeney, senior ecologist with the National Parks Association of NSW, said an analysis of the NSW RFAs showed they have “completely failed to deliver the ecologically sustainable forest management that was the centrepiece of the Agreements and are therefore a failed model for forest management.” [17]

The RFAs look as if they were meant to indulge both sides: a dazzling array of new parks and reserves for the conservationists, and a promise to the industry of high volumes of timber based on inflated estimates of the resource, and a low regulatory bar.

It was a mistake to let the RFA negotiations proceed with so little public scrutiny. Allowing these untried agreements to run for 20 years was an even bigger mistake; however, given that the Carr government entered the process with 20 year wood supply commitments to Boral and Daishowa – made by the previous government – it is hard to see how things could have turned out differently.

The ‘bush conservationists’ of NEFA and SEFA certainly did a deal. But their intentions were good and, like the rainforest campaigners of 1975-82, they made important gains for nature conservation.

The RFAs were supposed to end the war in the forests but the environment movement and the timber industry are now shaping up for another fight. Both have upped the ante: one side calling for an end to all logging in native forests, while the other is intensifying its native forest harvesting and dressing up its economic case with schemes like the burning of forest wastes, or ‘biomass’, to generate electricity. 



Between these competing visions of total protection and industrial forestry, lies the possibility of a return to old-style selective logging for wood products of only the highest value; but it is doubtful that economics would justify such low volume operations, or that the industry could be trusted to control its appetite.

There is a good environmental case for protecting all NSW native forests in parks and reserves, especially those in the north east which possess biodiversity values of global significance. There is also a good economic and financial case for ending native forest logging. This is based on the losses it makes for the Forestry Corporation – $11m a year – the costs it imposes on taxpayers and ratepayers, and the small amount of employment it provides. An Australia Institute study has concluded that “changes to the Commonwealth’s Emissions Reduction Fund to include native forest protection, would make conservation the economically obvious choice”. [18]



––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––



[1] Hannam, Peter (2017) ‘ “Preposterous”: Rainforest damage goes unpunished after EPA fails to act.’ Sydney Morning Herald December 2, 2017. http://www.smh.com.au/environment/preposterous-rainforest-damage-goes-unpublished-after-epa-fails-to-act-20171201-gzwq5y.html

[2] O’Brien, Natalie (2015) ‘EPA let time expire in which to prosecute Forestry Corp over road in koala reserve’ Sydney Morning Herald January 3, 2016. http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/inquiry-called-for-into-relationship-between-government-agencies-20151224-gluqak.html

[3] O’Brien, Natalie (2015) ‘Six investigations underway into operations of state-owned corporation.’ Sydney Morning Herald, December 13, 2015. http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/six-investigations-underway-into-operations-of-stategovernment-corporation-20151209-gljcl7.html

[4] Hannam, Peter (2017) ‘NSW EPA critical of conflicts of interest, complexity of native forestry bill.’ Sydney Morning Herald August 7, 2017. http://www.smh.com.au/environment/nsw-epa-critical-of-conflicts-of-interest-complexity-of-native-forestry-bill-20170806-gxqlk8.html

[5] Pugh, Dailan (2016) ‘A Conservationist’s Perspective on Conservation in North East NSW.’
http://dailanpugh.com/cms/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/A-brief-conservationists-history.pdf

[6] Pugh Dailan (2016) ‘Part 1. In the Beginning there was Rainforest.’

[7] Prineas, P. and Elenius, E. (1981) ‘Why Log Terania Creek?’ Supplement to the ‘National Parks Journal’ June 1981, Vol. 25 No. 3. http://teraniacreekinquiry.blogspot.com.au

[8] Pugh Dailan (2016) ‘Part 1. In the Beginning there was Rainforest.’

[9] Pugh Dailan (2016) ‘Part 1. In the Beginning there was Rainforest.’

[10] Pugh Dailan (2016) ‘Part 1. In the Beginning there was Rainforest.’

[11] Pugh Dailan (2016) ‘Part 1. In the Beginning there was Rainforest.’

[12] Pugh Dailan (2016) ‘Part 7. Finalising the Forest Assessment.’

[13] Pugh, Dailan (2016) ‘Part 4. A Fresh Start in New South Wales.’

[14] The NSW government deployed its big guns at RACAC: Mr Gerry Gleeson, Chair; Mrs Gabrielle Kibble, Director-General of Urban Affairs and Planning; Mr Roger Wilkins, Director-General, The Cabinet Office; Dr Col Gellatly, Director-General, Department of Land and Water Conservation; Ms Robyn Kruk, Director-General, National Parks and Wildlife Service; Dr Hans Drielsma, General Manager, State Forests of NSW; Dr Neil Shepherd, Director-General, Environment Protection Authority. The other members were: Mr Gary Ella, Department of Aboriginal Affairs (Acting Representative); Mr Col Dorber, Industry Representative; Mr Dailan Pugh, Conservation Representative; Mr Gavin Hillier, Union Representative; and Mr Phillip Glyde, Commonwealth Representative.

[15] Forestry and National Park Estate Act 1998, Part 4., Div. 4.

[16] Commonwealth Regional Forest Agreements Act 2002, Section 6.

[17] Sweeney, Dr Oisin, In Nature Conservation Council of NSW media release (11 May 2016) ‘Review of evidence concludes Regional Forest Agreements a failed model for forest management.’
https://www.nature.org.au/media-releases/2016/05/review-of-evidence-concludes-regional-forest-agreements-a-failed-model-for-forest-management/

[18] Campbell, R. and McKeon, R. (2016) ‘Money doesn’t grow on trees. The financial and economic losses of native forestry in NSW.’ The Australia Institute.
http://www.tai.org.au/sites/defualt/files/P209%20Money%20doesn%27t%20grow%20on%20trees%20-%20NSW%20Forestry%20Final%20Final.pdf






Writer Peter Prineas with his sons Cleon (left) 
                                                           and Alexander (right), April 2023.